
This one’s not going to seal up until 2009 when the BBFC actually takes over and the shit does or doesn’t hit the fan.
Earlier this year, the Byron report recommended the BBFC take control of all game rating in the UK for titles aimed at the over 12s, where up until now the BBFC had had a lesser involvement. This has lead to all sorts of industry outcry in defence of the popular and voluntary Pan European Game Information board (PEGI).
The industry is concerned the BBFC involvement will mean UK delays and additional costs, while the BBFC swears it is capable of upping its staff and seeing things through.
The latest couple of developments have involved the BBFC taking an outright swipe at PEGI (where so far they had always played the ‘we want to work together’ card), claiming it was unprofessional and slow.
“The trouble is that it is not clear who PEGI is,” David Cooke told The Times. “Administration is handled by the Dutch film regulator, who subcontracts to a couple of blokes [the Video Standards Council] in Borehamwood.” He also pointed out that the BBFC turn around time is around 25% faster than PEGI’s, and that having an independent board in each country helps to reflect that country’s cultural sensibilities.
Fair point, David, but when your cultural sensibilities mean we can’t play Manhunt 2, I’d rather stick with the Dutchies. No, we haven’t forgotten about that one.
More recently, Nintendo, Sega, Ubisoft and EA all banded together under ELSPA to attempt to drive a nail through the BBFC’s plans by declaring their official support for PEGI in an industry wide press release.
“Keith Ramsdale, Vice President and General Manager of EA UK, Ireland and Nordics, said: ‘The Government’s proposed changes will create extra administration and cause delays in getting hit games into the hands of British consumers. Only PEGI is built to address the fast changing nature of the games industry and is best placed to deliver the needed protection for minors.’”
I don’t for a second think that there isn’t more going on behind the scenes than the players are letting on. It’s all politics, smoke and mirrors.
I’m not pro-BBFC for obvious reasons, but I am for a legally enforceable and reliable ratings service, and there’s no concrete evidence to suggest the BBFC can’t pull that out of the hat.